Sunday, 22 October 2017

Post #2 - To SSR or NOT to SSR THAT is the question!


https://www.middleweb.com/25256/can-we-talk-about-sustained-silent-reading/What is SSR and is it valuable? I can’t say that this is a question I have been loosing much sleep over. To be honest, until I read Amber Rain Chandler’s article “Can We Talk About Sustained Silent Reading?’ I had no idea what SSR was or the dialogue that surrounded it. I found this article on the MiddleWeb website, which you could access by clicking on the site logo displayed for your convenience.

So what is SSR Exactly?

SSR is an acronym for Sustained Silent Reading, which is essentially uninterrupted, in-class reading time. Yes, this basically means no answering questions, keeping readings logs, making journal entries or any such activities. For a certain period of time in class, it’s just the student and the world that exists in the book of his or her choice.
Perkins, Hilary. (07/09/09). “Hamlet for kids” (Photograph). Retrieved from [http://bit.ly/2yFRxsB]
Now opinions on time used in class this way varies drastically. Take for example this article ‘Why Sustained Silent Reading(SSR) Doesn’t Work’ written by Mark Pennington and published on the Pennington Publishing Blog. This article goes on to list 8 reasons why SSR,  used as a tool for teaching reading, doesn’t work. Some of the reasons provided could be seen as direct failures to meet expectations of the Ontario Language Curriculum. For example one argument made is that SSR is not teaching at all, how can SSR fit into the classroom if there is no guidance from the teacher and there is no instruction to help students read critically?
Another example is that it provides no opportunity for reader response. In other words, there are no comprehension questions, no check for understanding of stylistic elements and no means to demonstrate understanding of the text they are reading.
These are failures to meet some of the general expectations of the curriculum and are therefore valid arguments and are worth some consideration.

On the other hand, there are many others who, like Amber Rain Chandler, sing the praises of SSR. Take for example this video listing the benefits of SSR created by Renee Burr:




Renee Burr emphasizes many things in her video, including the ideas that students are beaten over the head with reading comprehension but are not given the time to practice actual reading; that silent reading can be more important that oral reading because struggling students can get more actual reading done silently; and that the ideal is for students to find their own purpose for reading and make their own meaning from reading rather than be told how to think about texts from their teachers. These too all seem like very valid arguments to me that also merit some consideration.

... well I have considered …


I would like and say that it really took me a long time to figure out where I fall on the 'to SSR or not to SSR' argument but... nay. After reading the two articles listed here and watching Renee Burr's video I have already made up my mind. Like both Burr and Chandler decided, I do believe there is a place for SSR in the classroom. However, also like the two ladies I've mentioned, I do believe that SSR shouldn't be implemented in the classroom on it's own but rather in conjunction with other reading activities. Chandler decided to have her students convince their peers to read a book they particularly enjoyed. This activity would have demonstrated reading comprehension and furthered enjoyment by making reading social. Burr suggested that since SSR is most effective when embedded in a program that encourages dialogue it may be best to implement it in conjunction with read alouds, one on one conferencing with students and guided reading.
TTarasiuk. (11/09/09). “img_0608” (Photograph). Retrieved from [http://bit.ly/2z01N1U]

Personally I agree thoroughly with these ideas and, although I am not certain how SSR implementation would look in my classroom just yet, I will definitely be using their advice to make it work. The idea that in order to become fluent, independent readers students need to read frequently and develop the skills used in reading for different purposes (including enjoyment) is quite clearly stated in the Ontario Curriculum. What better way to foster reading for pleasure than to give them time to engross themselves in a book they actually want to read and remove the stigma of the 101 questions that come with academic readings?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Post #4 Let's Talk

From what I can remember of my time in school, emphasis in the language arts has always been put both on the reading and writing strands. Fo...